Cheyenne throws in with two friends on their quest for gold and riches, but greed has a poisonous affect on the partnership.
Episode Notes
- Rod Taylor, star of The Birds, guest stars as Clancy.
- The plot, situations and dialogue for this episode are lifted from the 1948 movie The Treasure of the Sierra Madre, starring Humphrey Bogart.
- This is the first time Clint Walker appears shirtless in the series.
- This episode is retold in comic book format in Cheyenne Comic Number 3.
Real World References
- The Argonauts were men from Greek mythology searching for the Golden Fleece.
Continuity Nitpicks
- Cheyenne tells Clancy he lived with indians for eight years. While this is true, later episodes will flesh out Cheyenne's childhood as being raised by indians since he was an infant.
Plot

Cheyenne meets Duncan and Clancy, who suspect him of being a bandit.

Cheyenne hesitantly joins the men on their prospecting trip.
Later, Clancy spots a group of indians coming toward the claim and Cheyenne identifies them as renegade Mescaleros. Duncan accuses Cheyenne of signaling the indians, but Bodie blows him off. The three of them dig in for an attack. After trading bullets, the indians take their horses and are chased away by an Army patrol.

Duncan is nursed back to health after a cave in.
Come daylight, Duncan and Clancy continue on and soon they're bickering along the way. That night, Duncan plots to take Cheyenne's share since he's not around to claim it. Clancy refuses to let him and Duncan demands they part ways. Duncan's paranoia reaches a fever pitch and he shoots Clancy. The next morning, Duncan decides to hide Clancy's body but it has disappeared. He takes off with all three burros. Meanwhile, Clancy is found still breathing by the same indians who Cheyenne is currently with. They bring him to their camp and Cheyenne nurses him back to health. The pair head out after their treacherous partner.

Mescaleros catch up to Duncan at a vulnerable moment.
Quotes
"Gold can play some funny tricks on men. I've seen it."
- - Cheyenne sums up the entire plot of this episode in 11 words.
"I've been fiddle-footed all my life. Guess that comes from living with indians for eight years when I was a kid. 'Cept that that don't seem right some how. I figure there's a place for every man where he can kinda settle down and feel like he's come home...if he can only find it. "
- - Cheyenne describes himself.
"You mean give her some of our gold?"
"Yeah."
"You're crazy."
"We've had all the luck. He didn't have any. Seems to me it wouldn't hurt if we shared ours."
"You sound like a preacher."
"Now what's wrong with that?"
- - Duncan and Clancy spar over the idea of giving a share of gold to Cramer's widow.
"Livin' around white men, sometimes indians look real good to me." - Cheyenne lets Duncan know he's disgusted with him.